Friday, April 15, 2011

Reflecting on Dragon Age 2

I haven't posted in two weeks now, partly because school has been keeping me very busy since spring break, as we're nearing the end of the semester, and partly because I've been spending most of my free time finishing up Dragon Age 2. In short, I loved it. It's not perfect, but still I found it highly enjoyable.


Spoiler notice: There may or may not be one or more dragon fights in Dragon Age 2.

First, some general, scattered, non-spoilery thoughts on the game, though I already shared some non-spoiler notes in my Spring Break: Kirkwall post.

In many ways, Dragon Age 2 seems like an attempt to Mass Effect-ify (Mass Affect?) Dragon Age: Origins. Or perhaps, to be more fair, to take elements of Mass Effect 2 that worked well and put them into Dragon Age. The most obvious example is the main character, Hawke, who is not only named but fully voiced, much like Mass Effect's Shepard. This gives less freedom in character creation than Dragon Age: Origins, and subsequent playthroughs will always feature essentially the same character; even if you can play as a different class or gender and make different choices, you're still Hawke of Lothering. I'm not really bothered by that, though. Dragon Age 2 is driven by the personal story of Hawke, running alongside what may become world-shaking events, rather than driven directly by those events. I wouldn't choose that for all my games, but in this case I found it to be very satisfying. I thought it worked. And DA2 still has a lot of replay value.

In Dragon Age: Origins, I played through all six of the origin stories, but I only got all the way through the game once. I didn't think another round would make me change any of the decisions I made the first time. In Dragon Age 2, I was sufficiently torn by some of the decisions I had to make that I definitely plan on playing through again with a different character, so I can see what happens if I make alternate choices. Not all of the credit for my desire to play through again can be given to the story, though. In Dragon Age: Origins, I liked the mage skills so much above other skills that I didn't feel like playing as anything else. In Mass Effect 2, even, I was such a Vanguard enthusiast that all of the other classes I tried never got very far--I missed my biotic charge and my shotgun. In Dragon Age 2, I thought that each class had skills that were fun and varied enough that I could play through as any class...except maybe a sword and shield warrior (no offense to shield enthusiasts, but so far, only Hellgate: London has convinced me that shields are more fun than an extra or larger sword).

Another noticeable Mass Effect adoption was the dialogue wheel. In a game where the player character lines are voiced, it would be redundant to display the dialogue options in their entirety; instead, a "wheel" of short choice descriptions are given, prompting the corresponding dialogue. I liked the dialogue wheel's implementation in Dragon Age 2 better than in Mass Effect 2. In Mass Effect, there are generally three options: paragon, renegade, and neutral. I was playing a paragon character, so I almost always chose the paragon option. Choosing one side and sticking to it was even encouraged, since earning a lot of either paragon points or renegade points was advantageous for the player character. In Dragon Age 2, the three main options are diplomatic, humorous, or aggressive, and concentrating on one over the others does not give you gameplay benefits. I felt more comfortable switching between them, which is more natural, anyway: just because I like to be diplomatic in general doesn't mean I can't get angry in certain situations, or try to make a joke to avoid conflict in tense situations.

Quick note on one aspect in which Dragon Age 2 was much better than Mass Effect 2: load times. For whatever reason, Mass Effect 2 had horrendous load times. I just figured that my computer was getting too old to run new games efficiently, but Dragon Age 2 load times were just a few seconds on my computer. Well done.

Dragon Age 2 was outstanding in terms of party member banter. Wherever I walked, a cute or sometimes thoughtful conversation between my companions was never far away--even more so than in Dragon Age: Origins. Sometimes when I went to visit a companion in their "home base", I'd catch the end of a meeting between that companion and another one. Whether friends or rivals, these people felt like they interacted with each other just as much as they did with me. It was great. That said, the companions had much less chit-chat with the player character than in Dragon Age: Origins. Nearly all conversations with a companion were quest-based, even if the whole quest was simply to talk to the companion. I learned a good bit about each companion throughout the course of the game, but I still wished we could have talked more--hear what they thought about events in the game, about other party members, about my romance. I did come to love my companions but...I wanted more.

Dragon Age 2 was a darker game than the original. The companion characters were on the whole a more troubled lot than those in DAO. And even with the blight over, the local situations in Kirkwall were pretty grim. I probably killed a lot more people in DA2 than in DAO, where my targets were primarily darkspawn. Lines between good and bad were not so clear, unlike in the fight against darkspawn. And some quests had elements that seemed to be out of horror movies. I was a bit traumatized by one such quest.

All in all, I loved Dragon Age 2. It was well written, engaging, challenging, and fun. The plot is a bit second-part-in-a-trilogy, but that can be a good thing. I am anxious to start a (dual-wielding) rogue and see how the game goes with a different set of choices.


To the rescue!

Here are some amusing quotes I jotted down while playing. Mostly Varric, as might be expected. No spoilers in them. I think they're all from Act III, since I didn't start to write any down before then, though I know there were some good ones in the first two acts. Next play through...

Varric: (mocking Comtess Dulci de Launcet's recent exclamation about a popular tavern) "Oh, but Ze Hanged Man is so filthy!"
Fenris: It is filthy.

Varric: You're a mage. You must know something about...weird..shit. I'm sure you'll be able to figure something out that will help.

Varric: Edwina, let's get a couple of drinks here.
(This one is a BioWare inside joke from Baldur's Gate II. Nice, after a couple Minsc/Boo references in Mass Effect 2. Any other good references I missed in Dragon Age 2?)

Merrill: (teasing about being in love with Hawke) Every time she looks away you stare at her with sad puppy-dog eyes.
Fenris: There are no puppy eyes.
Merrill: It's all right you know. Even you can be happy once in a while. It won't kill you. But your face might crack if you smile, so be careful.

Hawke: So I shouldn't slit my wrists and dance naked under the moonlight?
Varric: I would pay to see that.

Varric: Andraste's dimpled buttcheeks!

I know I missed a lot of good ones. Anyone have a favorite to share?


And now for the spoiler section (here until the end) in which I discuss/question/rant about specific parts of the plot, mainly for discussion with others who have played the game. Please give a spoiler warning if posting spoilers in the comments.

***SPOILERS***SPOILERS***SPOILERS***SPOILERS***
***SPOILERS***SPOILERS***SPOILERS***SPOILERS***
***SPOILERS***SPOILERS***SPOILERS***SPOILERS***

One thing I have to say I loved in Dragon Age 2 were cases in which the scenery moved. I don't know why this should have been such a big deal, but it was. Actually I'm thinking of two unrelated but enjoyable cases. First, the haunted house (that was once Bartrand's estate). When I walked into that first room and saw the vase levitate, a chill went up my spine. It was unexpected and creepy. (Though not as outright scary as the spiders dropping down from the ceiling in dark caves--I visibly jumped on more than one occasion because of this, mainly because of the startling sound that would accompany the spiders.) The other case was when the statues came to life in the final battle. Kirkwall is known for its unsettling statues made to break the spirit of the slaves in the city, so seeing them climb down off the walls and attack was thrilling. I liked the emaciated slave statues flopping onto the ground, then pulling themselves up to attack. Very cool.

This is just a question, in case anyone else caught it: Do all Dalish Keepers use blood magic, or just Merrill? When she uses blood magic at the beginning to get to the altar, I thought it was implied that she knew what she was doing because all Keepers have always used blood magic. And anyway, it would be a little impractical if the Keeper herself couldn't get to that altar, not using blood magic. But later in the game, I got the impression that Merrill was a bad, bad girl in her tribe for using blood magic, and that she learned it from the demon to cleanse the Eluvian. So which of these did I misunderstand?

Ah, Anders. Biggest WTF moment in the game. Given his last conversation with the player character before the events of the end game, it was clear he was up to something. I thought maybe he'd leave me--like, have a demon baby or something?--but I never thought he would, you know, blow things up like that. I wanted to know, though, how exactly he blew up the Chantry. Was it magic? I couldn't help notice the red glowiness of the explosion. The idol was red and glowy...so was the boss at the end of Act I, and all of Meredith's powers associated with the idol-forged sword. So I wondered if the big Chantry bomb was related in any way. Or was it simply a normal bomb, made out of that sela petrae and drakestone we got him? It didn't look like a normal explosion.

In any case, it was after the big boom that I had to stop playing on Sunday night to go to school the next morning. All I could think about all day was finishing the game that night...and what I would do with Anders (initially I had spared his life, but it was a short enough battle and skip-able dialogue sequence that I could easily redo that interaction). I was torn.

If I had romanced Anders, I think my decision would have been easier--I would have spared his life. But I had romanced Fenris, so I had no such attachment. Still, I was a mage, myself. But I wasn't sure what that meant. Should I be thanking him for what he's done? Or should I be furious that he just made things so much harder for mages? Maybe he was right, though--that the Circle didn't--couldn't--work. I had lived as an apostate my whole life, so why shouldn't I feel as though other mages should enjoy that? Here is perhaps where my having played as a mage in DAO was tainting my decision. Whatever Anders insisted about the Ferelden Circle tower, I didn't have such bad memories there as the Grey Warden mage. OK, they'd planned to make my friend Tranquil, but it turned out he was a trouble-making blood mage, so he brought that on himself. And there had been the big fiasco where tons of mages became abominations, but I'd never blamed that on the templar. The templar in the Ferelden tower may have been a bit annoying, but I didn't hate them (side note: nice to see how bashful young Cullen grew into a good man). And Wynne never seemed very bitter about her long life in the Tower. Anyway, perhaps contrary to what my apostate Hawke should have thought, I didn't think it was impossible for the Circle to work. So I couldn't condone what Anders did.

This is where I thought my options failed me. I was inclined to agree with Merrill: letting Anders die a martyr was letting him off easy--he got us mages into this mess, he'd better help protect the mages he got sentenced to death. After the mages are safe, then maybe we can find some way to punish him. But allowing him to rejoin your party makes it seem as though you support his actions. And it feels a little too much like "Yeah, let's go kill us some templar!" I wanted to let him know my fury, that he was still in big trouble...but let him live. But I couldn't do that.

I was also planning ahead a bit for my playthroughs. In retrospect, I think it would have made the most sense, given that I was playing as a mage, to romance Anders, side with the mages, and escape with him in the end. But I was going for maximum difficulty, I guess, in that I'd planned to romance Fenris as a mage and Anders as my next character, a non-mage. But I'd also planned on supporting the mages as a mage, and the templar as a non-mage. I'm guessing this won't work--if you side with the templar, you probably can't run off with Anders. So much for my plan. Realizing this just complicated the decision process.

And then there was Sebastian. I haven't finished the game yet sparing Anders' life, but I'm guessing nothing really happens with Sebastian by the end of the game. But who knows what could happen in a sequel? Anders was the one who frakked up, not Sebastian, so I didn't want to do anything that would endanger Sebastian in the future. That wouldn't be fair.

In the end, I chose to kill Anders. I felt I had to. I tried my best to put myself in my Hawke's shoes. What it came down to was that I couldn't trust him anymore. He went behind my back, killed a lot of innocent people, put so many more innocents' lives at stake, and he would have done it again (as opposed to Isabela in Act II, who came back to return the book, putting her own life in danger in regards to Castillon). I detest killing in cold blood, but when that's the only option the game gives you, what can you do? Besides, it's what he wanted, in a way.

So you can see, this was a complicated decision for me. And I thought the game was the better for it. Sure Meredith and Orsino both turned out to be...over the edge...in the end, but for most of the game I could see each of their sides. Meredith somewhat less so, but there would be moments when she'd admit that she knew it wasn't fair, she just felt she had no choice. It was very interesting interacting with her as a mage, at least on the few occasions that it came up. I was relieved that by Act III it was clear everyone knew I was an apostate--I'd been wondering about that in Act II.

I really can't wait for a sequel. I don't know how they'll do it, with Hawke or with the Grey Warden or what. But seeing Leliana there with the Seeker... Things have gone to hell. Hawke was there at the beginning, she can help fix things. And we still don't know what's happening with Morrigan, and Flemeth. Exciting indeed.

12 comments:

Hezabelle said...

I want!!! (it was hard for me to not read the spoilers because I want to know what happened! But I refrained...)

Eleni said...

You should get it! Many, many hours of fun...

Hezabelle said...

But that's the problem... I get so obsessed and I don't do anything else until I finish the game! So best to not start it so soon after the first...

Eleni said...

Yeah, I know what you mean. Probably wise to space it out.

Vanessita said...

Finally finished my first playthrough! (**SPOILERS**)I thought Morrigan and Flemmeth's plans would unwind on this one, but it seems they showed up only to build up anticipation for a next game.
People complained a lot about this game in the forums, but aside the repetitive scenario and a few recurrent bugs I hope they'll fix soon, it was lots of entertainment to me. I can't wait to start with a second character and make a different set of choices.

Something that really bothered me though was how previously known male characters (Anders, Alistair, Zevran) are ugly in the new version, while Leliana seems to be 20 years younger, not to mention Isabella, absurdly younger and hotter in a change not even blood magic plus modern surgery would be able to conceive (her response to the king was funny, at least). And what’s whith the giant boobs everywhere? Shameless boy fanservice, really? I couldn’t help but to imagine a bunch of married men laughing together as they inserted King Alistair’s line, referring to his Queen, the hero of Ferelden (the only gameplay I imported so far) as “ball and chain”, someone frightening he wanted to flee from (after all she/I’ve been through to make her Queen, lol). But my “canon" choice was the martyr ending.

This time I decided to start with the male character as a warrior (I usually play the female paragon first) and choose the humorous lines. The default male Hawk looks so likeable, handsome and outgoing to me. I had the same idea you did, to play a female mage and romance Fenris, then a rogue and romance Anders or Sebastian next. Did you have a friendly romance or a rival romance with Fenris? I take it he’s hard to please as an apostate mage (could be interesting).

Since I wasn’t playing paragon, I killed Anders too. I guess there was no right decision on this one, since that makes him a martyr for other apostates, and I felt compassion when he said that he didn’t tell me because I could, worse than stop him, decide to help. But he was annoying the entire game, focused on his goal despite the means to it, a different kind of abomination, but still one. The complete opposite of the naughty, playful Anders from Awakening. Throughout the whole game it was very difficult to pick a side from mages and templars. Even thought it seemed wrong to control the mages so tightly, it was a necessary evil, and even those you help can lose control and turn against you in the end, still the hero has the vivid memory of his kind sister, or could be an apostate him/herself. I supported the templars and was feeling guilty for Orsino, until he too surprised me. It’s a shame Meredith went mad and the nice chantry lady (forgot her name) died. Bad as things were, it was probably better and easier to work it out than in Tevinter. When I play paragon I’ll bring him along to make up for his poor choices (you can do that, even supporting the templars, I brought Merril along and was wondering what would become of her, since she would be the only mage left).

The red in Meredith’s powers was said to be lyrium, so I guess Anders explosion was made of the materials he asks of the hero plus lyrium, maybe a mix of magic items and the explosive powder from the Arishok?

What happened to your Hawke’s mother? I was wondering if it’s always the same or just a bad choice I made. Have you asked the brothel owner for something that would blow your mind (lol)?

Where are the champions/heroes going, I wonder? At first I thought it was just a way out from a common place happy ending, not having to explain what happened, but the conversation in the end made it seem like something more could be happening... or I just had the wrong impression, maybe.

Eleni said...

Yeah, they're clearly planning a Dragon Age 3, so hopefully Morrigan and Flemeth will be important in that one. I wonder how it will go, though, since depending on player choices Morrigan may or may not have some sort of demon soul...baby.

I got a little annoyed about seeing the same cave everywhere. It just seemed lazy. But it was helpful that I knew all the nooks and crannies to look in for items.

They did really weird changes to the faces for this game. I don't know what went so wrong, especially with Zevran. Previously he'd had such finely chiseled cheekbones, and somehow it became this amorphous mass. I thought Isabela looked good, though, except for the rather ridiculous boobs and the lack of pants. Seriously, I don't know how it was on other people's computers, but for me her butt was too curvy for her outfit, and would occasionally stick out of the little tunic she wore due to weird clipping or rendering artifacts (I don't know the proper terms...but it's a graphics glitch that happens when the clothes and the body exterior overlap).

I didn't hear the "ball and chain" line. I guess Alistair was always a joker, and if he wants to call Anora that (if you choose the ending making them king and queen), that's fine, but I'd be a little offended if he were talking about my Hero of Ferelden.

I actually had a friendly romance with Fenris, somehow got that to work out even though I was a mage and sided with the mages a lot. I felt the need to befriend everyone in my party, but now I'm regretting that, because they designed the game so it was good to have either friendship or rivalry, and in the case of Fenris with a mage it would have made more sense as a rivalry. I wonder how it changes the romance, though.

I never did get Awakening, not sure why, but I'm definitely regretting it now, because there are things that tie into DA2 (like Anders). I liked Anders most of the time (though I was pissed at the end). He was tortured, sure, but also fed the stray cats and was sometimes funny. It's interesting that you can keep him alive even if you side with the templars. It seems kind of cruel to make him kill all the other mages, and I don't see how he'd agree to it. I guess I'll have to find out.

Having played as a mage in Origins, and playing a mage again in DA2, I didn't see how the strict locking up of mages in Kirkwall was a necessary evil. I also didn't see Anders' side that the Circle Tower couldn't work, and mages needed to be completely free. Unfortunately, the end of the game doesn't really give room for compromise. I had sided with the mages, so I was really annoyed at Orsino when he gave in and became an abomination. Definitely surprised me. I was really glad that Meredith went totally crazy so that even Cullen and Carver (my Carver had become a templar) fought along side me, and I didn't have to kill them.

Hawke's mother died for me, and I'm pretty sure it always happens. I played through the whole quest and when I found out she died, I went back and re-did the quest using Gasgard (the younger mage, whom I hadn't killed in the previous quest) to find them, hoping that that way we could find her faster before he'd done his nasty...thing to her. Played all the way through again and still found her beyond saving. I found that extremely disturbing. They (the game designers) were so cruel! Having to see her hobbling along like a zombie. It was like out of a horror movie or something. Sad, too.

It'll be interesting to see where the Champion and Hero are going. Is it something to do with Morrigan? With the war between mages and templar? Or something new? I wonder where the next game will take place. Maybe Orlais?

Eleni said...

Oh, and no I haven't asked the brothel owner that... I'll have to go do that now :)

Vanessita said...

I only hope they really do a third game, instead of DLCs for that... I’m taking Fenris around much more now, and he had some intriguing lines about the Witch of the Wilds.

The same glitch with Isabella’s (lack of) clothes happens here. Zevran’s face change specially was very disappointing... in his case, I guess it had to do with the general changes on the elves. Though the previous elves were nice, I thought the new ones to be more original, with their big eyes, strange interesting noses and slender frames. But they could have been more generous with Zevran, no need to change his face so much!

I was upset with Anders change, but he is still nice, guess they just wanted to make him look a little older (still not the same applies for Isabella). I’m growing fonder of him now that I’m playing with a female mage and we agree most of the time, he’s sweet. But as the story says, he’s merged with a spirit of Justice, and now is obsessed with justice for mages. He’s very deep with the relationship too (a bit scary sometimes).

Awakening had some interesting info on the darkspawn. I got upset though when I realized you can’t romance anyone (how could they? after all the flirting and gifts! I would have let Anders come onto me more if I wasn’t interested in someone else first).

Anders is a comely guy on Awakening, and the cat he mentions (Sir Pounce-a-lot) is there -- it’s a gift actually, that stays in the inventory and can be used in and out of battle. His face looked a lot like Alistair’s and it seemed to me the voice actor was also the same (a bit annoying at first, but sexy). Since then he flirts with the player, woman or man (not very sexy for me, in particular :P). And Justice, the one who merges with him in-between the stories, is also a party member. It’s sad that together they become potentially dangerous. Justice was a calm, kind being and would soon need a new body (he was walking around in a corpse, not a pretty sight), so you see how they came to the idea of merging. I see from the wikia there are quests that can only be triggered by importing saves with certain choices from Awakening, or using one of the default backgrounds provided.

I said it was a necessary evil because in DA2 unfortunately the possession seems to happen to all the mages, in a matter of time (kinda sad, I thought going through the ritual and coming back was enough). Of course it doesn’t happen to the main character, the kind hearted mage sister (with reasons) and Merril so far is an exception too (not too right in the head from the start, maybe that’s why :P). The ideal, I guess, would be to have filacteries of all mages secure and some kind of surveillance, like periodic tests, and keep the templars at disposal, I don’t know, but not restraining them like they all committed murder, no wonder many revolt that way.

Oh, the “blow your mind” brothel option is for the male character, I didn’t know! The “bad girl” option is also funny!

It just dawned on me that, with Sebastian Vael’s DLC, for the first time, we girls have actually more options than guys (if you count chaste romances)! Yes! ^^

Vanessita said...

I found this and thought you might find interesting:

If Fenris Were In Origins,
part 1: http://equinexus.deviantart.com/gallery/#/d3d0zeh

part 2: http://equinexus.deviantart.com/art/DA-If-Fenris-Were-In-Origins-2-203540155

part 3: http://equinexus.deviantart.com/art/DA-If-Fenris-Were-In-Origins-3-204330763

and this:
http://fakehonestytruelie.deviantart.com/art/Fenris-Poster-203272772?q=sort%3Atime%20gallery%3Afakehonestytruelie&qo=1

Eleni said...

I just took Fenris to Sundermount and found his little exchange with Flemeth to be very interesting! First time through I missed it because I did Sundermount before getting Fenris. Obviously DA3 will have to address the mess that's going on with the templars vs. mages, but it had better also have Flemeth and Morrigan.

I thought the new elves were very cool, too, slender with bigger eyes and ears. More unique. But to change an already established face like Zevran's was unnecessary.

I think I have to get Awakening now and play through it so I can appreciate more in DA2. I don't know why I didn't get it in the first place when it came out. It definitely sounded like there was more to the Sir Pounce-a-lot story, haha.

I know, it seems like every mage in DA2 turns into an abomination! The first time through, since I didn't realize Anders would be a party member, I actually thought he was turning into an abomination there in the Chantry in that first quest with him, and that I'd have to fight and kill him there. I'd just finished the quest where Thrask's mage daughter turns into an abomination right in front of you, and I thought, "Oh no, not another one!" when Anders' eyes started glowing and he spoke in the weird voice. I guess in retrospect, there were a lot of demon mage possessions in DAO. there was Connor's near possession, and the possession of tons of mages in the Ferelden Circle, but somehow it still didn't seem so common place. It was something to be aware of, but the point of the Harrowing was to prove your ability to resist demons. Anders and Merrill just had an interesting conversation in my party, about the difference between spirits and demons, and how her blood magic has to do with demons whereas Justice is just a spirit. I guess if you play as a spirit healer, then you are working with a spirit, and thus arguably very similar to Anders.

You're right! Women have more romance options! What a historic event :)

Hehehe, those Fenris links are pretty funny. It would get so nasty between him and Morrigan...

Saad ali said...

Thanks a lot for sharing. You have done a brilliant job. Your article is truly relevant to
my study at this moment, and I am really happy I discovered your website. However, I
would like to see more details about this topic. I'm going to keep coming back here.

Architectural Walkthrough
Architectural Visualization
Architectural Rendering
3D Animation
Product Animation
3D Modeling
Corporate Presentation
3D Images
Real Estate Publicity
Multimedia Presentation
Saad Ali Cool

Black Smith said...

I can see that you are putting a lot of time and effort into your site and detailed articles! I am deeply in love with every single piece of information you post here
Surgical instruments
Dental Instruments
Beauty instruments
Neurosurgery Instruments
ENT instruments
Gynecology instruments
Orthopedic instruments
Ophthalmology
Hollow wear Utensils
Veterinary instruments
Surgery Sets